Taste and judgment

What good means, and how a person learns to see it.

These sources deal with judgment that resists a checklist. Some define taste, and some exercise it in a review or a list. Others try to draw intent out of people.

Part of The Tacit. 13 sources from 11 subjects. A source can carry several themes. These tags are this wiki's own reading, not claims the sources make.

Related themes: How forms evolve, Who holds the power.

The Concept of the Aesthetic

James Shelley (Auburn University), Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. From Art movements and theory.

A philosophy encyclopedia entry tracing how the concept of the aesthetic developed from 18th-century taste.

Human Judgment as a Specification

Brown PLT blog. From Checkable specs for coding agents.

A tool that recovers intent by asking people about concrete disagreements.

A beginner's guide to modern classical music

Luke Muehlhauser. From Consonance and tuning.

A personal blog guide grouping modern classical pieces by accessibility.

43 of the Most Iconic Short Stories in the English Language

Emily Temple (Literary Hub). From Fiction and literature.

A Literary Hub list of short stories the editor calls iconic in American culture.

The Closet — Browse Every Criterion Spine

Oliver and Patrick Evans. From Film, animation and video.

A fan-made web app for browsing every spine in the Criterion Collection.

The Firemen: Hot stuff

Kimimi. From Games and game design.

A blog review of The Firemen, a firefighting action game for the SNES.

A defense of philosophical intuitions

Hilarius Bookbinder (Scriptorium Philosophia). From Mind, attention and practice.

An essay arguing that intuition is a mental faculty as legitimate as perception or memory.

Developing Taste

Emil Kowalski, Design Engineer. From Review, taste and expertise.

A short essay on taste as a trained instinct and how to build it.

You can't unit test for taste

Karl Tryggvason. From Review, taste and expertise.

A developer's write-up of a map pipeline built with Claude and its evaluation problems.

Ethics is the most important skill in a post-AI world

Not stated (company blog of Agonora). From Society and technology.

A company blog essay arguing that ethical judgment is the key skill after AI.

The Resonant Computing Manifesto

Fifteen named contributors, including Maggie Appleton and Simon Willison. From Society and technology.

A manifesto calling for software built on five principles that it says make technology resonant.

How To Not Die By A Thousand Cuts. Or, How To Think About Software Quality.

Aditya Athalye. From Software tools and craft.

A personal essay argues that software quality is everyone's job.

Blogging Can Just Be Stating The Obvious

Jim Nielsen. From Writing and the small web.

A short post arguing that a good blog post can say what seems obvious.